Pedestrians and Drivers Disagree, Who Really Pays the Price?

Pedestrian walking home from school, waiting for the green pedestrian light, and stepping onto a crossing, only to be hit by a car. That’s exactly what happened to 12-year-old Jessica Rose Gadsby, who suffered serious injuries in an accident that changed her life. But what followed was just as distressing: a legal battle over who was truly at fault. The driver claimed the light was red, while Jessica’s sister, who was with her, insisted it was green. Two versions of the truth. One decision that would determine justice.

This case, Jessica Rose Gadsby v Julie Hayes [2024] EWHC 2142 (KB), recently made headlines because it shows how difficult it can be to prove what really happened after an accident. It’s a reminder that in personal injury cases, having the right legal support is just as important as the evidence itself. At Claim Today, we know that accident victims deserve answers, not doubts. That’s why we fight for people like you, ensuring that the facts are uncovered, your rights are protected, and you get the compensation you deserve.

On October 31, 2014, in Leicester, Jessica was walking home from school with her sister, Kacie. They reached a pedestrian crossing, and according to Kacie, the green man was on, signalling it was safe to cross. But as Jessica stepped onto the road, a car driven by Julie Hayes hit her. Jessica suffered injuries, and her family was devastated. When the case finally went to court, the driver told a very different story. She claimed the pedestrian signal was red, meaning Jessica had stepped onto the road at the wrong time.

The problem? This case was being judged years later, and there was no CCTV footage. The only evidence was witness testimonies and expert opinions. The court ultimately ruled in favour of the driver. The judge reasoned that memories fade over time and that earlier statements made closer to the accident date held more weight. This ruling raises a crucial question: When there’s a legal dispute over an accident, how do you prove what really happened?

Jessica’s case is a painful example of what happens when injury victims don’t have strong legal support from day one. At Claim Today, we work fast to collect the right evidence, speak to witnesses early, and build the strongest case possible—so your claim doesn’t suffer because of fading memories or lost records.

✅ We Act Fast, So You Don’t Lose Crucial Evidence
Time is everything in personal injury claims. The longer you wait, the harder it becomes to prove what happened. That’s why we work immediately to gather witness accounts, medical reports, and accident details while they’re still fresh.

✅ No-Win, No-Fee – So You Have Nothing to Lose
Unlike many legal firms that charge upfront, we take on your case with zero financial risk. If we don’t win, you don’t pay. That’s our commitment to fair justice for everyone.

✅ We Handle Everything – You Focus on Recovery
From speaking to insurance companies to negotiating settlements, we handle every part of your claim, so you can focus on healing, not paperwork.

✅ We Fight for You, Not Just Your Case
We know that a personal injury claim isn’t just about money—it’s about fairness, dignity, and making sure what happened to you doesn’t get ignored.

The legal system isn’t just about truth—it’s about proving the truth. And without the right legal team, justice can slip away. If you or a loved one has been in an accident, don’t wait until it’s too late. Act fast to build a stronger, unbeatable claim.

📞 Call us now at 0800 29 800 29
💻 Start your claim today

Accidents happen in seconds. Justice should never take years. Let’s get you the compensation you deserve—starting today.

How can I help you? :)

06:33